I disagree. I think Shane just snapped, or got so angry that he threw the wrench without thinking. I doubt there was true malicious intent - premeditated murder, if you will - beyond the wrench chuckin'

Shane is a hothead, we all know that. He takes a lot of actions without thinking through the consequences first. And they were in the middle of a very emotional and physical fight. Men like Shane (who is a former law enforcement officer and obviously trained in physical confrontation) often have only two speeds. Stop or All Hell Breaking Loose. There is no in between setting.

I'm not excusing what Shane did, by the way. It was a very lethal action against Rick. Just not so sure it was premeditated with INTENT to kill as many members seem to think.

Anyway, what say you? Vote, comment, call me nuts ... it's all good.

This post has been edited by tex: Today, 10:01 PM